Why Today's So-Called Positional Value is a Hoax

                                     photo: courtesy of ESPN

By Walter Mitchell

In recent years, numerous fans and draftniks have been insisting that positions such a running back, guard, center, nose tackle, inside linebacker, slot cornerback and safety are not 1st round "value" positions.

What I have been trying to explain for several years now is how Tom Brady and Patrick Mahomes proved by virtue of their combined 10 Super Bowl rings, is that winning the middle of the football field with a passing game that features tight ends, slot WRs and RBs on circle routes is the modern-day key to NFL success.

As a result, order to contend for championships, defenses need to be very strong up the middle, particularly in boasting a stud interior defensive lineman to go with highly versatile and athletic inside linebackers, slot CBs and safeties.

For example, let's take a look at the last three Super Bowl winners on defense. 

2023 Kansas City Chiefs

DI - Chris Jones --- 84.1

ILB - Nick Bolton --- 70.6

SCB - Trent McDuffie --- 82.9

S - Bryan Cook --- 65.3

2024 Philadelphia Eagles

DI - Jalen Carter --- 74.1

ILB - Zach Baun --- 90.1

SCB - Cooper DeJean --- 82.7

S - C.J. Gardner-Johnson --- 75.1

2025 Seattle Seahawks

DI - Leonard Williams --- 75.3

ILB - Tyrice Knight --- 76.2

SCB - Nick Emmanwori --- 71.0

S - Julian Love --- 82.2

Note: of the Cardinals returning players on defense this year, only DI Walter Nolen (in 6 games) had a grade higher than the 65.0 average NFL grade for starters last season. 

The Cardinals gave up 230.8 yards passing in 2025.

2023 Chiefs --- 176.5 --- #4 in NFL

2024 Eagles --- 174.3 --- #1 in NFL

2025 Seahawks --- 193.9 --- #10 in NFL


2025 Arizona Cardinals

DI - Walter Nolen III

ILB - ?

SCB - ?

S - Dadrion Taylor-Demerson


Let's Fix This:

#3 --- Sonny Styles, LB, Ohio St. --- most athletic defender in draft

#34 --- Keionte Scott, SCB, Miami FL --- best slot CB in draft

#65 --- Landon Robinson, DI, Navy --- has Aaaron Donald traits

#104 --- Skyler Bell, WR, UConn --- slot baller

# 143 --- Travis Burke, T, Memphis --- big, brawling RT

#183 --- Levi Heidenreich, RB/FB, Navy --- Swiss-army RB 4.4 speed

# 217 --- Jakobe Thomas, S, Miami FL --- clutch cover FS

Trade Proposal:

Cardinals send Zaven Collins to the Vikings for Jonathan Greenard

Trading for edge rusher Jonathan Greenard could be such a boon for the Cardinals. Vikings want to move him because he wants a new contract in the $20M a year range. His 2026 base salary is $18M. 

Greenard is 28, coming off a 3-sack season despite a stellar pass rush win rate of 23%. Opposing QBs were getting the ball out quick versus the Vikings' pass rush. 38 career sacks in 77 starts. 

Cardinals signed Josh Sweat at age 28, 4 years $76M with $41M guaranteed. Sign Jonathan Greenard for similar deal and the Cardinals have a formidable pair of bookend edge rusher for the next few years. Having that in place before next year's QB bonanza in the 2027 NFL Draft would be especially smart.


2026 Arizona Cardinals

DI - Walter Nolen III

ILB - Sonny Styles

SCB - Keionte Scott

S - Dadrion Taylor-Demerson


Strengthening the middle of the defense could give the Cardinals a chance to be competitive, sooner rather than later.



Kurt Warner
@kurt13warner
It’s so funny to hear everyone talk about the risk of certain guys/positions in Top 10… everyone is a risk until they aren’t, until they become a pro-bowler or superstar & once they do no one cares where u drafted them! 95% of these guys have to get better than they were in college to be special… and no one knows which ones that will be, so they are all risks! I’ve never understood anything but taking the best player available or the best at position of need based on the only metric you have: College tape!!


Comments

  1. RedrunApril 23, 2026 at 7:27 AM

    I can get on board with this, I just say take a NT (McDonald or Hunter) with pick #34 trade back into rnd 2 pick 50 or earlier with picks 65 and future pick to land Scott (or Ponds). Having a good NT free's our ILB to make plays.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Image
 Clayton Tune: The Fateful Path of an NFL Legacy by Walter Mitchell photo: @azcardinals.com via Instagram During the second night of the 2023 NFL Draft, Clayton Tune received a call from the Green Bay Packers. The Packers wanted to assure Clayton of their interest in drafting the University of Houston quarterback at some point on day three.  When the Arizona Cardinals selected Clayton Tune with the #139 pick a day later, he was surprised, given that the Cardinals had not expressed any significant interest in him during the pre-draft process. The Cardinals were not one of the six teams that brought him in for 30 visits (Texans, Saints, Browns, Steelers, Bucs, Giants). Tune had also been given a private workout by the Rams. The eventual link the Cardinals had to Clayton Tune was that Israel Woolfork was one of his coaches at the Senior Bowl. At that time, Woolfork had just finished his second year of a Bill Walsh/Bill Willis coaching fellowship with the Cleveland Browns.  A...
Read more
Image
  Drew Petzing Deserves More Praise Than Derision                                       image courtesy of @azcardinals.com By Walter Mitchell On X yesterday, there was this chance for Cardinals' fans to grade Jonathan Gannon, Drew Petzing and Nick Rallis thanks to @BirdmanofAZ. Bird Droppings @BirdmanofAZ Bye week report card.......coaching staff Jonathan Gannon ________ Drew Petzing ________ Nick Rallis ________ Here are the average results thus far of the fans' grades: Jonathan Gannon: D Drew Petzing: F Nick Rallis: C Why is it that Drew Petzing has drawn such abject scorn from Cardinals' fans? Going back to last year, the PHNX Cardinals media site has been waging a daily campaign to see Drew Petzing get fired, that is if he can't coach up a weekly magical connection between Kyler Murray and Marvin Harrison Jr. This season, in light of Kyler Murray's inconsistencies and Marvin Harriso...
Read more
Image
 Was Will Johnson's Red and White Interception Staged? by Walter Mitchell photo thanks to Tyler Drake at Arizona Sports Cardinals' 2nd round pick, CB Will Johnson of Michigan, is off to a fabulous start just 10 days into training camp.  Will Johnson has come to the Cardinals just as advertised. He is a keenly instinctive zone cover corner who reads his man and the QB extremely well, which enables him to jump routes and make timely pass breakups and interceptions.  In man coverage, he lacks the requisite recovery speed to stay sticky on speedy receivers. But that's ok, as long as the coaches match him up with receivers whom he can run stride for stride with.  We have yet to see whether the 2024 concerns about Will Johnson's tackling, which may have been due to injuries. With him presumably taking over Sean Murphy-Bunting's starting role, the coaches will have to hope that he tackles way better than SMB (29.4 2024 PFF tackling grade). If you look at Will's 2023 ga...
Read more